Paw Paw/Moonlight
Home / Up / Creek Chub / Heddon / Paw Paw/Moonlight / Pflueger / Shakespeare / South Bend / Flies & Fly Rod Lures / Misc Makers

 

Paw Paw Fishing Lures For Sale

What's New
4/6 - added 1 lot
1/7 - added 2 lots
10/3 - added 4 Paw Paw/Shakespeare lure lots
6/17- added 3 lots

Click on Item# for picture(s)

Item# Description Price
lm169 Paw Paw Baby Jointed Pikie #2105 -  This is a beautiful MINT IN THE BOX lure made by Paw Paw Bait Co. It is in the rainbow color and comes with the correctly marked '2105' box.  Does have a tiny chip by the tail.  Sold
sh88
 
Shakespeare/Paw Paw Lucky Dog #L8504 - very nice circ 1970's wooden lure made by Shakespeare. The lure is NEW IN THE BOX. and comes with paperwork.   Sold
sh89
 
Shakespeare/Paw Paw Krazy Kritter #L2493F - very nice circ 1970's wooden lure made by Shakespeare. The lure is NEW IN THE BOX. and comes with paperwork.   Sold
sh90
 
Shakespeare/Paw Paw Midget Flap Jack Assortment #L6600 -  very nice circ 1970's wooden lure assortment of 7 lures made by Shakespeare. The lures are NEW IN THE BOX. and comes with the dealer display box. The #'s are L6630, L6625, L6607, L6658, L6671, L6670 and L6603. $95.00
pp33
 
Paw Paw Crippled Minnow #1508 - very nice wooden lure that is MINT IN THE BOX. It has painted tack eyes.  Sold
pp34
 
Paw Paw Crippled Minnow #1506 - very nice wooden lure that is MINT IN THE BOX. It has painted tack eyes.  $49.00
pp37
 
Paw Paw Empress Spoon Counter Display - here is an exceptional collectable piece. It is a store counter display with all 6 Empress Spoons still intact. The lures are MINT ON THE CARD and the card itself is in EXCELLENT condition.  $150.00
pp40
 
Paw Paw Pikie - very nice 1930's wooden lure with painted tack eyes. Both eyes are fine. In beatiful rainbow color pattern. Lure is in EXCELLENT condition.  Sold
pp44
 
Paw Paw Surface Minnow - I believe this is a no eye surface minnow made by Paw Paw. It is probably from the 30's maybe earlier. Prop is unmarked and the lure is in EXCELLENT condition. Sold
pp46
 
Paw Paw Fluted Pikie - very nice 1930's wooden lure with painted tack eyes. The lure is 4 1/2 inches long and in EXCELLENT condition. Sold
pp47
 
Paw Paw Baby Pikie - nice 1940's wooden lure with painted tack eyes. The lure is 3 3/4 inches long and in VERY GOOD PLUS condition. Sold
pp48
 
Paw Paw Wotta Frog Jr. - this is a very nice wooden lure with painted tack eyes. Two rear hooks still has some of the original hair. The lure is in EXCELLENT condition and comes in the correctly marked box. Sold
pp49
 
Moonlight Pikaroon #1000 - nice early 1920's wooden lure with glass eyes. Both eyes are fine. Lure looks like it might have been over varnished but still in VERY GOOD PLUS condition. Tough lure to find. Sold
pp50
 
Moonlight Pikaroon #1000 - nice early 1920's wooden lure with tack eyes. The paint is off both eyes. This is a little later version than the glass eye version. Lure looks like it might have been over varnished but still in VERY GOOD  condition. Tough lure to find. Sold
pp51
 
Paw Paw Lucky Lure Baby Jointed Pikie #2106 - nice 1940's wooden lure with painted tack eyes. Paint off one eye. Lure is in VERY GOOD PLUS condition and comes in the correct box. Sold
pp52
 
Paw Paw Wotta Frog #72 - nice 1940's wooden lure with painted tack eyes. Lure is in EXCELLENT MINUS condition. This is the smaller of the 2 sizes of Wotta Frogs.  Sold
pp53
 
Paw Paw Pikie - nice 1940's wooden lure with painted tack eyes.  Lure is in EXCELLENT condition. Sold
pp54
 
Paw Paw Old Faithful #4400 - nice 1940's wooden lure with painted tack eyes.  Lure is in EXCELLENT condition. Sold
pp55
 
Paw Paw Wounded Minnow - nice 1940's wooden lure with painted tack eyes.  Lure is in EXCELLENT condition. Sold
pp56
 
Paw Paw Midget Jointed Pikie - nice 1940's wooden lure with painted tack eyes.  Lure is 3 1/2 inches long and in EXCELLENT MINUS  condition. Sold
pp57
 
Paw Paw Midget Jointed Pikie - nice 1940's wooden lure with painted tack eyes.  Lure is 3 1/2 inches long and in EXCELLENT MINUS  condition. Sold
pp58
 
Paw Paw Jointed Trout Caster - nice 1940's wooden lure with painted tack eyes.  Lure has a couple of small chips to the paint as seen in the pictures. Still a nice VERY GOOD PLUS lure. Sold
pp59
 
Paw Paw Slim Lindy #2400 - nice 1940's wooden lure with painted tack eyes.  Lure is in EXCELLENT MINUS condition. Paint is off the belly weight. Sold
pp60
 
Paw Paw Midget Jointed Pikie - nice 1940's wooden lure with painted tack eyes.  Lure is 3 1/2 inches long and in EXCELLENT MINUS condition. Sold
pp61
 
Paw Paw Jointed Pikie - nice 1940's wooden lure with painted tack eyes.  Lure is 4 1/2 inches long and in EXCELLENT MINUS condition. Sold
pp62
 
Paw Paw Jointed Pikie - nice 1940's wooden lure with painted tack eyes.  Lure is 3 3/4 inches long and in EXCELLENT MINUS condition. Sold
pp63
 
Paw Paw Jointed Pikie #9100J  - very nice 1940's wooden lure with painted tack eyes.  Lure is in EXCELLENT  condition. Sold
pp64
 
Paw Paw Bass Oreno Type Lure - very nice 1940's wooden lure with painted tack eyes.  Lure is in EXCELLENT  condition and comes in a box. I don't know if it is the correct box. Sold
pp65
 
Paw Paw Pikie - very nice 1940's wooden lure with painted tack eyes.  Lure is in EXCELLENT  condition and in a pretty rainbow color pattern. Sold
pp66
 
Moonlight Bait #1 - this is a limited commemorative bait made in 2001. It is MINT IN THE BOX and comes with the paperwork. $17.50
pp67
 
Moonlight Pikaroon #1000 - nice early 1920's wooden lure with glass eyes. Both eyes are fine. Does have some age lines and tiny chips to the paint. Overall condition is VERY GOOD PLUS. Sold
pp68
 
Paw Paw Flap Jack #3633 - very nice circ 1940's plastic lure that is MINT IN THE BOX. The box is correctly marked and in nice condition. $39.00
pp69
 
Paw Paw Flap Jack Phantom #3407 - very nice circ 1940's plastic lure that is MINT IN THE BOX. The box is correctly marked and in nice condition. Sold
pp70
 
Paw Paw Swimming Mouse #4642 - very nice circ 1940's painted tack eye wooden lure in the zebra color pattern. The lure is NEW IN THE BOX. Box is correctly marked. Sold
pp71
 
Paw Paw Wotta Frog #73 - very nice circ 1940's painted tack eye wooden lure. The lure is in EXCELLENT condition and comes in the correctly marked box. Sold
pp72
 
Paw Paw Old Faithful #4400 - very nice circ 1940's painted tack eye wooden lure in an iridescent color. The lure is in EXCELLENT condition. Sold
pp73
 
Paw Paw Pikie - very nice circ 1940's painted tack eye wooden lure. No paint loss on the eyes. The lure is in EXCELLENT condition. Sold
pp74
 
Paw Paw/Moonlight Plunker #2201 - nice 1930's wooden lure with painted tack eyes. It is in silver flash color pattern and in VERY GOOD PLUS condition. Sold
pp75
 
Paw Paw/Moonlight Bass Seeker #2700 - nice circ 1920's wooden lure with painted tack eyes. The lure is in VERY GOOD condition. Does have some paint loss at nose. Sold
pp76
 
Paw Paw/Moonlight 99% Weedless - nice circ 1920's wooden lure. The lure is in VERY GOOD PLUS condition. Does have some slight chipping at the weed guard. Sold
sh151
 
Shakespeare/Paw Paw Piky Getum #L2130 -  very nice 1970's wooden lure with glass eyes. This is a Paw Paw style lure made by Shakespeare. The lure is NEW IN THE BOX and comes with a pocket catalog. $35.00
sh152
 
Shakespeare/Paw Paw Pup #L8878 -  very nice 1970's wooden lure with glass eyes. This is a Paw Paw style lure made by Shakespeare. The lure is NEW IN THE BOX and comes with a pocket catalog. In the beautiful pearl color finish. $35.00
sh153
 
Shakespeare/Paw Paw Pup #L8896 -  very nice 1970's wooden lure with glass eyes. This is a Paw Paw style lure made by Shakespeare. The lure is NEW IN THE BOX and comes with a pocket catalog. In the beautiful red spot color finish. $35.00
sh154
 
Shakespeare/Paw Paw Piky Getum #L2196 -  very nice 1970's wooden lure with glass eyes. This is a Paw Paw style lure made by Shakespeare. The lure is NEW IN THE BOX $30.00
pp77
 
Paw Paw Jointed Pikie - nice 1940's wooden lure with painted tack eyes. The paint is missing on one of the tack eyes but overall condition is still EXCELLENT MINUS. $13.00
pp78
 
Paw Paw Popper - nice 1940's wooden lure with painted tack eyes. The lure is in EXCELLENT condition. $15.00
pp79
 
Paw Paw Slim Lindy - very nice circ 1950's wooden lure with painted tack eyes. The lure is in EXCELLENT condition. $15.00
pp80
NEW
Paw Paw Plunker - very nice circ 1940's wooden lure with painted tack eyes. The lure is in EXCELLENT condition. The lure is 2" long and in frog color. $20.00
I am looking to buy lures by the following makers. Prefer lures in excellent condition and if possible with the original box.
Abbey & Imbrie, Action Frog, Actual Lure, Airex Corp, Albyler Basgeter, Alcoe Lure Co, Frankin Alger, Allcock, Anderson Minnow, Apex Bait Co, Arnold Mouse, Artistic Minnow, J.J. Gill, Bomber,  Tony Accetta, Gee Wiz Bait Co, Fred Arbogast, Arnold Tackle, Babbitt Automatic Weedless, Detroit Bait co, Taylor Bass Charmer, National Bait Co, Bidwell Bait, Biek Manufacturing, Biff Bait Co, Bingo Bait Co, Bite-em-bate Co, Bleeding Bait, Bomber Bait Co, Brighte-eye-lure, Brooks Baits, Paul Bunyan Bait, Carterís Bestever Bait Co, Catís Paw, Charmer Minnow Co, Wallsten Tackle Co, Clark Co, Clewell Mfg, Coldwater Bait Co, Comstock Chunk, Cra-Bug Bait Co, Creek Chub Bait Co, Ed Cummings, Darby, Decker, Detroit Glass Minnow, Dickens Bait Co, Jim Donaly Baits, Eger Bait Co, Evans Weed Queen, Shaffer Expert Minnow, Woods Expert Minnow, Clark Expert Minnow, Keeling lures, Falls City Bait Co, Fetch-it Co, Fish Dinner Frog, Florida Shinner, Pemberton & Sons, Florida Fishing Tackle, Al Foss, Garland Baits, Stan Gibbs, Goble Bait, Go-Getter, Good Luck Lures, Haas Tackle, Halik CO, Jacob Hansen, Harkauf Minnow, Harris Frog, Hastings Sporting Goods, Heddon, Hinckley, Hinkle Lizard, Homarth Tackle Co, Isle Royale Baits, Jacobís Hoss Fly, Jamison Co, Johnson Automatic Striker, Jumpin Joe, Jersy Expert, K & K Manufacturing, Keller Weedless, Kent Frog, King Wiggler, Kimmich Mouse, Kinneyís Bird, Kingfisher, Laneís Wagtail Wobbler, Leaping Lena, Leeperís Bass Bait, Lehmanís White Wonder Bait, Lockhart, Wagtail Minnow Mfg Co, Long Island Manufacturing, Meyer Company, Manitou Minnow, Medleyís Wiggly Crawfish, Millerís Reversible Minnow, Wm Mills Tackle Co, Millsite Tackle, Moonlight Bait Co, Roberts Bait Co, Fred Nichols Lures, Nixon Underwater, Outingís Lure Co, Paw Paw Co, Joe Pepper, Pflueger, Pontiac Minnow, Rush Lures, Shakespeare, Silver Creek Novelty Works, Smithwick Lures, Sout Bend Lures, Strike-Master Lures, Tooley Tackle, Turbulent Fishing Lures, Welch & Graves, Wellers Classic Minnow, Wright & McGill

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

To Order:
Please confirm availability of item(s) and shipping costs either by phone or email before sending payment. I will accept a money order, bank check or personal check. If payment is made by personal check please allow 7-10 days for shipment otherwise shipment will be next day. I am NOT setup to accept credit cards directly. However, I do accept payment through PayPal but prefer a check or money order because of the PayPal fees. My PayPal account ID is mageg@msn.com. My phone # is 215-956-0993 and my email address is mageg@msn.com. I normally use the USPS Priority Shipping. Shipping costs will depend on weight and the destination zip code. Some of the longer 1 piece rods may have an 'oversized' shipping charge.

Contact Information:
Earl Grant
538 Fisher Lane
Warminster, Pa 18974
email - mageg@msn.com
(215) 956-0993

Copyright © 2001-2013 [Earl's Antique Tackle]. All rights reserved.
Revised: 11/22/13.